Fargo's Steakhouse - Payson, Arizona

Oleguer P.

Hemos comido muy bién!! Carnes muy buenas y la atención exelente. La chef Paty muy atenta y hospitalaria

toni A.

Muy buena experiencia para cenar

Mibzar V.

Solo puedo decir q m encanto

John N. I.

Firstly, the table service provided by Abbie was impeccable.

This steakhouse in Payson is recommended. The steak was delicious and cooked to perfection. It is likely that the onions would have been improved if sauteed. The chicken was good, but highly dependent on the impressive flavor of the sauce, being somewhat dry itself. The carrot cake was satisfactory, with a delicate cream cheese frosting of moderate sweetness. My dining companion and I were sated, and since this restaurant aims to a higher standard, we held it to one.

Although the steak is delicious here, I should add that the salmon is also fantastic. It comes with a variety of preparation possibilities, with the crusted coconut being my personal favorite. The artichoke dip pizza with chicken is also recommended.

Update 10-2-23
Considering our semi-frequent returns to this location, it is upgraded to 5 stars. We wouldn't return if it wasn't good!

Tamara S.

Came here for my mother in laws birthday and national sons day. Delicious food, great staff and nice atmosphere. I ordered the turkey bacon avocado gluten free wrap with seasonal fruit on the side. So good!

Marty L.

I recently ate at this restaurant and it was great! I had a steak sandwich with sauteed onions and mushrooms which is served with garlic mayo on the sandwich. It was so good I didn't want it to end. The server was very nice, knowledgeable, and was always there if we needed anything. I will go back but I don't know if I can order anything else besides that wonderful sandwich!

E4Skyd F. A.

First time visit. Arrived right before the Saturday night dinner rush about 4:30pm...and this place is POPULAR!! Our steaks (10oz sirloin $29/ea) were perfect! Tried the tortilla soup and garlic mashed potatoes with grilled Brussel sprouts and it was all so good! We had the key lime pie ($10) with vanilla bean ice cream (asked them to drizzle raspberry on it all) and it was homemade deliciousness!!! We will definitely return here!!

T K.

On January 24, 2025, at 1 PM, my wife and I decided to treat ourselves to lunch at Fargo's Steak House. My wife ordered a bacon burger, asking for it to be well done, but it arrived surprisingly pink inside. She chose not to complain, letting it go. I opted for the open-faced New York strip steak, requesting it medium well. However, the steak I received was much rarer, almost blood red. I sent it back, but when it returned, it was still too pink for my taste, so I ate around the better-cooked edges.

To my disappointment, the steak was riddled with gristle throughout, which made enjoying it even more challenging. Given that this is a steak house, I expected a higher quality cut, especially with it being a New York strip. I've had many NY strips over the years, and this was, without a doubt, the worst I've encountered. Although I'm not one to complain unless it's significantly substandard, this experience was notably poor. In retrospect, I should have spoken to the manager. I took the steak home, and my dog enjoyed it.

Writing this review is difficult for me because I don't wish to harm Fargo's reputation, but this experience was too significant to ignore.